Fishes of the genus Cottus –the sculpins—have long been a challenge for fish managers and ichthyologists in the West. They share streams, rivers, and lakes with trout and salmon, and depend on the same kinds of habitats with relatively cold, clean water. But because the morphological differences between species are subtle and seemingly geographically variable, it has been a challenge to catalog the diversity of species in western North America. To resolve this problem, we sought your help to build a regional collection of sculpin tissues, and used genetic sequences, species delimitation algorithms, and geography to delineate the number and distribution of species.
“Perhaps no group of fishes occurring in the fresh waters of California has given biologists (including the author) more identification headaches than sculpins.”
– Peter Moyle, 2002
“Despite the efforts of generations of ichthyologists, the taxonomy of northwestern Cottus remains tricky.”
– J.D. McPhail, 2007
Thanks to contributions by over 130 biologists, academicians, students, and citizen scientists, we received over 8,300 specimens–representing every described species–from over 1,500 locations in every state and province across western North America to which sculpin were native. We sequenced 1–4 genes for one or more sculpins from every location (over 4,000 sculpins in all). We supplemented those data with sequences downloaded from public sequence libraries, which were georeferenced by using data in those libraries, consulting the publication with which the specimens were associated, or searching records of museums with substantial ichthyological collections. We also included specimens of two species from eastern North America, C. bairdii and C. cognatus, that were believed to be present in western North America, and the type species for the genus, C. gobio, from Europe.
Key findings:
The current taxonomy recognizes 19 species from the region. We hypothesize that there are 37 species in 8 species complexes in western North America. These represent heretofore unrecognized species, previously recognized taxa resurrected from synonymy, and most of the currently recognized species.
Nearly all species can be diagnosed with a single mitochondrial gene. Knowing where a specimen was collected is nearly as informative.
A handful of currently recognized taxa showed little or no genetic differentiation from other species. We acknowledge that these taxa might be valid under other species concepts.
Hybrids among sculpin are common, and some species are of ancient hybrid origin.
Neither C. bairdii nor C. cognatus are found in western North America. We did propose, however, three new species within the former from eastern North America, and suspect that there may be others.
For further details, you can download the publication and supplemental materials describing this work from TreeSearch: Young, Michael K.; Smith, Rebecca; Pilgrim, Kristine L.; Isaak, Daniel J.; McKelvey, Kevin S.; Parkes, Sharon; Egge, Jacob; Schwartz, Michael K. 2022. A molecular taxonomy of Cottus in western North America. Western North American Naturalist 82(2): 307-345.
https://doi.org/10.3398/064.082.0208
Sculpin Qwest Presentations, Publications, and Posters